[47]
DEHUMANIZATION OF SIENA BY VIOLET
VIOLET TO ANTHONY;
Violet: “Are you actually returning to your bachelor lodgings in the city, or is there a certain soprano you intend to visit?”
SEE ALSO
AND
AI OVERVIEW
IT SHOULD BE NOTED THAT VIOLET DELIVERED HER NASTY, DEHUMANIZING WORDS IN A TREMBLING, HURRIED TONE, MEANING SHE WAS FULLY AWARE THAT HER CRUEL LANGUAGE COULD ESTRANGE HER SON FROM HER—AND WAS DEEPLY AFRAID OF THAT OUTCOME—WHICH IS EXACTLY WHAT LATER HAPPENED.
The Anatomy of the Hurried Voice
- The Fear of the Rupture: Violet is no stone-cold sociopath immune to her child’s feelings. She senses the immense emotional stakes. That nervous, hurried tone shows she knows damn well she is about to cross a line. She is aware that she is launching a frontal assault on the heart of her eldest son and is, at that exact moment, terrified that he will instantly estrange himself from her.
- Panic as Fuel for Cruelty: Her hurriedness is the pure survival tone of the Ton. In her mind, driven by her fear of social death, she feels she must launch this attack to save the family. Her nerves demonstrate that her subsequent cruelty stems from a deep, suffocating fear, rather than pure malice.
Why This Is No Excuse, But Greatly Magnifies the Tragedy
It is absolutely no excuse for her dehumanizing words. However, it makes the drama infinitely more layered. It proves that from the very first second, Violet knew she was playing with fire. She consciously took the risk of permanently damaging the relationship with her son, purely to save the superficial facade of society.
That hurried voice in Season 1 is the perfect predictor of the kille silence in Season 2. The fear she carries in her voice there is exactly the fear that later forces her, in his study, to keep Pandora’s box firmly shut. She already knew then what she was risking, and in Season 2, she knows she has paid that price.
[KEEPING PANDORA’S BOX SHUT REFERS TO THE FACT THAT HER APOLOGIES TO ANTHONY ARE SELECTIVE: SHE APOLOGIZES FOR HER EMOTIONAL ABSENCE AFTER HIS FATHER’S DEATH, BUT NOT FOR HER MUCH GREATER, ACTIVE EMOTIONAL DAMAGE TO HIM CAUSED BY THE SABOTAGE OF HIS LOVE AFFAIR WITH SIENA ROSSO. BECAUSE OF THESE SELECTIVE APOLOGIES, A PERMANENT EMOTIONAL ESTRANGEMENT AROSE BETWEEN THEM, EVEN AFTER HIS MARITAL HAPPINESS WITH KATE SHARMA.]